Roy Halladay, Retired Cy Young-Winning Pitcher, Dies In Plane Crash At Age 40
Roy Halladay won two Cy Young awards and was an eight-time All-Star during his 16 years in the major leagues. He’s shown during his final season, in 2013.
Matt Slocum/AP
hide caption
toggle caption
Matt Slocum/AP
For years, Roy Halladay stood not only atop the pitcher’s mound but atop Major League Baseball, too. Over the course of his career, the pitcher racked up two Cy Young awards and earned All-Star honors eight times. Even after retirement, he also achieved great heights — albeit in a different way, getting his pilot’s license and posting often on social media about his beloved new plane.
On Tuesday, that new avocation ended in tragedy. The Pasco County (Fla.) Sheriff’s Department confirmed that Halladay’s small aircraft crashed in the waters off Florida, killing him at age 40.
“Many know Roy as a Cy Young winner, a future Hall of Famer, one of the best pitchers to ever pitch in the game of baseball. We know Roy as a person, as a caring husband who loved his wife, Brandy, and loved his two boys tremendously,” Sheriff Chris Nocco said at a news conference Tuesday.
Nocco said Halladay even donated a dog to the sheriff’s office to serve as a K-9 officer.
Roy Halladay bought a dog for his local Sheriff’s office. This is K9 Doc. pic.twitter.com/kM7Rjj1UsK
— Blake Schuster (@Schustee) November 7, 2017
“He was probably one of the most humble human beings you’ll ever meet,” Nocco continued, later adding:. “You wouldn’t know what Roy did because Roy would never tell you what he did. And that’s the legacy of a great man.”
“We are numb over the very tragic news about Roy Halladay’s untimely death,” one of his former teams, the Philadelphia Phillies, said in a statement. “There are no words to describe the sadness that the entire Phillies family is feeling over the loss of one of the most respected human beings to ever play the game.”
We are saddened by the tragic news that Roy Halladay, 2-time Cy Young Award winner & 8-time All-Star, has died in a plane crash. He was 40. pic.twitter.com/SOFv3bOLyt
— MLB (@MLB) November 7, 2017
During Halladay’s 16 years in the league, he recorded a staggering 67 complete games — the most by any one player since he made his professional debut in 1998, according to MLB network columnist Jon Morosi. In 2010, he also pitched what was then only the 20th perfect game in MLB history.
He retired in 2013.
Roy Halladay’s cap and ball from his 2010 perfect game. His legacy lives on in Cooperstown. Rest in peace, Doc. pic.twitter.com/PqASdhK8bf
— Baseball Hall ? (@baseballhall) November 7, 2017
Lately, as discussion of his career turned to when he would be inducted into the Hall of Fame, Halladay himself turned to another passion: flight. Just last month, ICON Aircraft delivered one of its aircraft — the first of its kind — to Halladay, prompting a meditation on his love for flying.
“I’ve been dreaming about flying since I was a boy but was only able to become a pilot once I retired from baseball,” said Halladay, before going on to praise the plane he received, an A5.
What do clouds feel like? I didn’t know either until I got my new Icon A5! I’m getting bruises on my arms from constantly pinching myself! pic.twitter.com/BaObEUj3Xo
— Roy Halladay (@RoyHalladay) October 13, 2017
Authorities say they found him after a private resident reported a crash at about midday and officials launched an hours-long search-and-rescue effort. Law enforcement ultimately found Halladay’s plane in shallow water, with only Halladay onboard.
Nocco asked that people give the late pitcher’s family privacy.
On social media, his loss drew an outpouring of support from friends, teammates, rivals and even some admirers, whom Halladay inspired to pursue baseball themselves.
In shock over the terrible news about Roy Halladay… a pitcher I grew up admiring & rooting for. Praying for his family & friends. #RIPDoc
— Mike Trout (@MikeTrout) November 7, 2017
Heart is broken to hear about Roy Halladay .great friend, teammate, father and husband. One of the best teammates ever! You will be missed !
— Roy Oswalt (@royoswalt44net) November 7, 2017
It was our honor to share a field with the incredible Roy Halladay. Our thoughts and prayers are with his family, friends and fans. pic.twitter.com/rwtSYsgpgm
— Atlanta Braves (@Braves) November 7, 2017
Saturday Sports: Colin Kaepernick And The World Series
Attorneys for Colin Kaepernick are seeking the cellphone records of several NFL team owners in a collusion lawsuit. Scott Simon talks with ESPN senior writer Howard Bryant.
SCOTT SIMON, HOST:
Time for sports.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
SIMON: An NFL controversy sharpened this week. Attorneys for Colin Kaepernick want the cellphone records and emails of several NFL team owners in his collusion lawsuit against the league. We’re joined now by Howard Bryant of ESPN and ESPN the Magazine.
Howard, thanks for being with us.
HOWARD BRYANT: Good morning, Scott.
SIMON: And help us read the tea leaves on this one, if you could. Team owners don’t like to have their phone records subpoenaed, I’ll guess.
BRYANT: (Laughter) No, they don’t. And this is a collusion lawsuit where Colin Kaepernick hasn’t had a job this season. He hasn’t had a tryout, a physical, nothing. No one has tried to hire him. And he believes that this is a byproduct of him taking a knee last year and being a protester to police misconduct throughout the country – and that the league is paying him back for it.
So what he’s done is he filed a collusion lawsuit where you have to prove that at least two or more owners acted in concert to keep you from being employed. And so the way to do that is to create a paper trail. And that paper trail is being compiled right now through requests for cellphone records from NFL owners such as Bob Kraft of the Patriots and Jerry Jones of the Dallas Cowboys, Bob McNair of the Houston Texans. And what they’re trying to create is proof that this league conspired together to keep Colin Kaepernick from having a job.
SIMON: I mean, there have been several prominently injured quarterbacks in recent weeks. And you keep wondering why no one calls Colin Kaepernick.
BRYANT: Yeah – and replaced with players who are nowhere near as good as he. And so there’s – anecdotally, absolutely. You can look at this and you can say – yes, they do not want him in their league. However, the problem is is that anecdotally is not enough in terms of legal standard. You have to create that paper trail and find that smoking gun and all of these different other cliches that we use for compiling information.
And there’s been plenty of conversation about this as well in terms of the comments that a lot of the owners have made. And the White House has had a lot to do with this, where Donald Trump came out and talked about how he shouldn’t have a job and how you had the owner of the Giants come out earlier this year and talk about how his fan base didn’t want Colin Kaepernick and how the owner of the Baltimore Ravens, Steve Bisciotti, said something very similar.
And so there is plenty of information out there that would lead you toward this, which is why Colin Kaepernick made this action. However, once again, the burden of proof is very, very high – as you remember as a baseball fan in the 1980s when the baseball owners all agreed not to sign free agents. So they were essentially conspiring not to win games because they wanted to keep salaries down. And they got caught, and it’s been a rift between the owners and the players for the last 30 years. We’ll see what happens with this as well.
SIMON: Yeah. Very quickly, Papa John’s Pizza says that people aren’t buying as many pizzas because they don’t like football as much as they used to. Doesn’t occur to them that the pizzas might have something to do with it. Does it?
BRYANT: No. Or the – Pizza Hut actually trolled them as well to say – hey, nothing wrong with our sales over here.
SIMON: (Laughter).
BRYANT: It’s a lose-lose for everybody, Scott, when you think about it from an NFL standpoint – that you have people saying, well, we’re not watching the NFL because of the protests. And then you have people saying, no, we’re not watching the NFL precisely because of how you treated Colin Kaepernick. So the NFL would be wise to sit down with its players…
SIMON: Yeah.
BRYANT: …The way the NBA has. And the NBA has not been hit with this as hard as the NFL has. However, the culture of the NFL – owners versus players – is to really stick it to the players. And so far, there’s been no real conversation about putting this thing down and coming together.
SIMON: I think we have to end with a salute to the Houston Astros – won the World Series this week. I don’t forget an inexcusable racial slur of one of their great players. But boy, they were a great team.
BRYANT: And I think the two best teams played in the World Series this year. And I think we got a classic. It was fantastic. I think that if you’re the Dodgers, you’re proud of what you did. But you also know you probably should have won that series in five games. You had the lead in Game 2. You had the lead with your best player on the mound in Game 5. And it just didn’t happen for them. But credit to the Astros for fighting and fighting and fighting. And this is why you don’t quit.
I think one of the great things about this, too, is that the baseball was so good, it would just be nice to see baseball go to a couple of day games in the World Series.
SIMON: Yeah.
BRYANT: The next generation of fans didn’t get a chance to see this. A lot of the action took place at 1 o’clock in the morning.
SIMON: Howard Bryant, thanks so much.
BRYANT: My pleasure.
Copyright © 2017 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for further information.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.
Investigators Say No Sign Of Cruelty In Kennel Of Former Iditarod Champ
Four-time and defending champion Dallas Seavey mushes during the ceremonial start of the Iditarod Trail Sled Dog Race in Anchorage, Alaska, on March 4. Seavey has faced recent accusations of doping, which he denies, and animal cruelty, which local officials say is not supported by evidence.
Michael Dinneen/AP
hide caption
toggle caption
Michael Dinneen/AP
Officials in Alaska says they have investigated conditions at the kennel of four-time Iditarod winner Dallas Seavey, and found no signs of cruelty, as had been reported by an anonymous complaint.
Seavey made headlines last month when his dogs tested positive for a banned substance; Seavey has denied that he was doping and has withdrawn from the 2018 Iditarod dog sled race in protest.
After that story broke, PETA issued a statement asserting a “whistleblower” had sent the group evidence that a Seavey-owned kennel “allowed severely injured and ailing dogs to suffer—sometimes fatally—without veterinary care.”
The Matanuska-Susitna Borough investigated the allegations. In a press statement reported by KTUU, a borough spokesman says authorities “closed the investigation after finding no evidence of any violation—no evidence of failure to provide humane animal care and no evidence of cruelty to animals.”
“Alaska State Troopers also are separately investigating complaints against a kennel, but won’t identify the musher,” The Associated Press reports. “Borough officials and Seavey didn’t immediately return messages Thursday.”
Seavey came in second in this year’s Iditarod (behind his father, Mitch Seavey).
Houston Astros Are World Series Champions, Beating Los Angeles Dodgers
Los Angeles Dodgers Beat Houston Astros 3-1, Extend World Series to Game 7
The Los Angeles Dodgers pour onto the field after beating the Houston Astros in Game 6 of the World Series.
Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images
hide caption
toggle caption
Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images
Updated at 1:10 a.m. ET
The Los Angeles Dodgers beat the Houston Astros 3-1 in Game 6 of the World Series, evening the best-of-seven series at three games each and guaranteeing a Game 7 on Wednesday at Dodger Stadium.
The Dodgers had trailed 1-0 until the bottom of the sixth inning when catcher Austin Barnes singled and Houston starter Justin Verlander hit L.A.’s second baseman Chase Utley. Center fielder Chris Taylor doubled to score Barnes. Shortstop Corey Seager’s sacrifice fly scored Utley.
Until then Verlander appeared to be in control of the game, holding the Dodgers to just one hit in five innings.
The Dodgers added another run on a home run by left fielder Joc Pederson in the bottom of the seventh inning.
Los Angeles Dodgers’ Chris Taylor hit a RBI double off Houston Astros starting pitcher Justin Verlander during the sixth inning of Game 6 of the World Series Tuesday.
Jae C. Hong/AP
hide caption
toggle caption
Jae C. Hong/AP
For Houston, Game 6 was about their failure to capitalize on opportunities to get on the board. They scored their only run when Astros center fielder George Springer hit a home run off of Dodgers starter Rich Hill in the top of the third inning.
Houston Astros’ George Springer opened the scoring in Game 6 with a home run off LA’s Rich Hill at Dodger Stadium.
Alex Gallardo/AP
hide caption
toggle caption
Alex Gallardo/AP
The Astros threatened to score in their half of the fifth, sixth and seventh innings, but each time they came up with nothing.
In the top of the fifth inning, they had runners at second and third base with no outs after a single by catcher Brian McCann and a double by left fielder Marwin Gonzalez. Two outs later, and with an intentional walk to Springer loading the bases, third baseman Alex Bregman grounded out to short.
In their half of the sixth, the Astros got two runners on a two-out single by first baseman Yuli Gurriel. Then McCann was hit by a pitch from Dodgers reliever Brandon Morrow. But again, Houston failed to score.
Houston put two more runners on base in the seventh inning on a walk by right fielder Josh Reddick and an infield single by Springer. But the Astros couldn’t get a timely hit after that, leaving a total of eight runners on base.
Each of those scoring threats were stymied by the Dodgers relievers who combined for 4 1/3 scoreless innings after starter Rich Hill went 4 2/3 innings. Reliever Tony Watson was the game winner and Houston’s Verlander took the loss, his first since being traded to the Astros in late August.
The Dodgers colorful right fielder, Yasiel Puig, had guaranteed that the Dodgers would win Game 6 and force a winner-take-all Game 7.
The starting pitchers for Game 7 Wednesday night are Yu Darvish for the Dodgers and Lance McCullers for the Astros. Darvish pitched poorly in Game 3, lasting only 1 2/3 innings. McCullers was the victor as Houston won that game 5-3.
Not-So-Fun Run: Joggers In 'Gerrymander 5K' Must Run Oddly Shaped Route
Runners in the Gerrymander 5K will trace the boundary of two congressional districts that split Asheville, N.C.
Ken Lane/Flickr
hide caption
toggle caption
How do you make people understand the odd forms created by gerrymandering? Make them feel it in their toes.
That’s the idea behind the Gerrymander 5K happening Saturday in Asheville, N.C., which will trace the boundary between North Carolina’s 10th and 11th Congressional districts.
That line splits the left-leaning city into two districts that, when combined with more conservative rural voters, both end up represented by Republicans.
The route for the Gerrymander 5K, as drawn by its sponsor, the League of Women Voters of Asheville-Buncombe County.
League of Women Voters of Asheville-Buncombe County
hide caption
toggle caption
League of Women Voters of Asheville-Buncombe County
As the Asheville Citizen-Timesexplains, the route is not exactly a straight shot:
“Roughly speaking, they’ll begin at The Admiral at 400 Haywood Road, go west on Haywood Road, north on Martin Avenue, west on Balm Grove Place, north on Balm Grove Avenue, southwest on Florida Avenue, south on Dorchester Avenue, west on Haywood Road, north on Louisiana Avenue, east on Majestic Avenue, north on Brucemont Circle, west on Brucemont Road and north on Louisiana Avenue to the turnaround point near Patton Avenue. The return trip ends at West Asheville Lounge and Kitchen, 401 Haywood Road.
“For any poor souls following this on a map, runners and walkers will have the 10th District, represented by Rep. Patrick McHenry, R-Lincoln, on their right on the outbound leg and the 11th District of Rep. Mark Meadows, R-Buncombe, on their left.”
Good luck, runners.
The course creates “a visceral experience of how gerrymandering divides our communities and doesn’t make sense. Why include this house but not another?” Alana Pierce, president of the League of Women Voters of Asheville-Buncombe County, toldRunner’s World. The league is sponsoring the run/walk.
Gerrymandering is the drawing of districts in a way that gives one party an electoral advantage, generally by spreading the opposition across districts or packing its voters into as few districts as possible.
North Carolina’s congressional districts have been repeatedly challenged in court. The League of Women Voters has filed five lawsuits since the state was redistricted in 2011; the group wants a nonpartisan committee to redraw the districts.
Federal judges ruled in 2016 that two of North Carolina’s congressional districts were racially gerrymandered, spurring Republican legislators to hastily redraw the state’s district map. Now those districts are being challenged (including by the League of Women Voters), and a panel of federal judges will rule on their legality in the coming weeks or months.

This map shows the zigzagging line separating North Carolina’s 10th and 11th Congressional districts. The Gerrymander 5K will take place in West Asheville, circled here.
League of Women Voters of Asheville-Buncombe County
hide caption
toggle caption
League of Women Voters of Asheville-Buncombe County
“North Carolina has some of the worst partisan bias in the country, both under the 2011 and 2016 maps,” says Michael Li, senior redistricting counsel at the Brennan Center for Justice at NYU School of Law, a nonpartisan law and policy institute.
He tells NPR that the state’s congressional districts consistently favor Republicans “to an unnatural degree.”
“We did a study and we found that North Carolina is among the top three states for bias. It gives Republicans a 10-3 bias in a state that votes 50-50,” Li says. “When it comes to the congressional map, Republicans have had a safe 10-3 majority for most of a decade.”
Republican state Sen. Ralph Hise, chairman of the state Senate’s redistricting committee, has called a nonpartisan redistricting commission “mythical.”
Back in western North Carolina, the Gerrymander 5K has been more than a year in the making. J.P. Kennedy, an artist, musician and documentarian, was angered by the adoption last year of HB2, known as “the bathroom bill.”
“I was so outraged that we were treating our transgender community this way,” Kennedy told the Raleigh News & Observer. “I was like, ‘Who’s my representative?’ That’s when I started seeing how crazy our North Carolina maps were.”
Kennedy and his family and friends used a bucket of sidewalk chalk to draw the sinuous district boundary through the community. Then his wife, Cinnamon, also an artist and musician, had a different idea to demonstrate the line’s strange shape.
“My wife said, ‘People in this community love 5Ks. … Why not make the district line a racecourse and have people out there on it so they can see and experience the problem?’ ” Kennedy told Runner’s World. “I thought that was brilliant.”
Though the district’s boundary will make for a notably strange racecourse, the Brennan Center’s Li says that funny-shape districts are a symptom of a problem — not the problem itself.
After all, North Carolina’s 10th and 11th don’t look especially strange by the standards of American congressional districts.
“You have to look behind the map,” Li says. “The real problem isn’t that the districts are ugly. The problem is that they lock in a 10-3 vote in a state that is 50-50.”
Houston Astros Win Game 5 And Take 3-2 Lead In World Series
Game 4: Dodgers Outlast Astros To Tie Up World Series
Joc Pederson of the Los Angeles Dodgers celebrates hitting a three-run home run in the ninth inning.
Christian Petersen/Getty Images
hide caption
toggle caption
Christian Petersen/Getty Images
The Los Angeles Dodgers evened the stakes Saturday night, outlasting the Houston Astros in a drawn-out rally that quickly escalated into a 6-2 victory in the final inning.
The Dodgers’ Joc Pederson sealed the late comeback with a three-run homer off of Astros pitcher Joe Musgrove in the top of the ninth inning.
Remarkably, Game 4 remained scoreless all the way through the fifth inning, as Alex Wood completed a historic outing as the first Dodgers pitcher to carry his team through five World Series innings without allowing a hit. Meanwhile, the Astros’ Charlie Morton, who let in three hits, wasn’t far behind the starting pitcher. But Astros’ George Springer broke both the no-hit bid and the tie in the bottom of the sixth inning with a left-field homer.
Dodgers’ longest WS no-hit bids:
5+ Alex Wood 2017-4
4? Sandy Koufax 1963-1
4 Ralph Branca 1947-1
4 Carl Erksine 1953-3
4 Koufax 1965-5— Doug Kern (@dakern74) October 29, 2017
The Dodgers evened things up in the seventh inning as Cody Bellinger scored off of a single from teammate Logan Forsythe.
But it wasn’t until the top of the ninth that the Dodgers blasted ahead with five runs. The Astros took one run in the bottom but it wasn’t enough to recover.
Chatter leading up to Game 4 focused on Astros’ Yuli Gurriel who, just hours before Saturday’s game, escaped a World Series suspension for making a racist gesture toward Dodgers’ Yu Darvish in Game 3. MLB commissioner Rob Manfred did pull him out of a handful of games next season, but tonight, the first baseman received a standing ovation from a noticeable amount of Astros fans.
Game 5 is scheduled for Sunday night in Houston.
Houston Astros Beat The Los Angeles Dodgers 5-3 In Game 3 Of World Series
Houston Astros’ Carlos Correa and George Springer celebrate after winning Game 3 of the World Series.
Eric Gay/AP
hide caption
toggle caption
Eric Gay/AP
Updated 12:40 a.m. ET
The Houston Astros defeated the Los Angeles Dodgers in Game 3 of the World Series at Minute Maid Park in Houston, taking the series lead with two wins over the Dodgers.
The Astros relied on early scoring and a gutsy relief effort by right-hander Brad Peacock who came in for starter Lance McCullers with one out in the sixth inning and held the Dodgers without a hit for 3 2/3 innings. He struck out four and surrendered a walk.
McCullers went 5 1/3 innings, giving up three runs and four hits for the win.
With their victory tonight, the Astros are 7-0 in their home park in this postseason.
Houston got on the score board first by opening the bottom of the second inning with a solo home run by first baseman Yuli Gurriel, followed by a double by right fielder Josh Reddick. Designated hitter Evan Gattis walked. A hard-hit single by left fielder Marwin Gonzalez scored Reddick. Catcher Brian McCann followed with another single, scoring Gattis and making the score 3-0. The Astros added a fourth run when third baseman Alex Bregman hit a sacrifice fly to center, scoring Gonzalez.
Houston Astros’ Yuli Gurriel celebrates his second-inning home run in Game 3 of the World Series against the Los Angeles Dodgers on Friday.
David J. Phillip/AP
hide caption
toggle caption
David J. Phillip/AP
Dodgers starter Yu Darvish was pulled for reliever Kenta Maeda after Astros second baseman Jose Altuve smoked a double to center field. Maeda managed to get the final out without further damage.
The Dodgers threatened to come back immediately in the top of the third after their first three batters earned walks. But they scored only one run when shortstop Corey Seager grounded into a double play.
The Astros added their fifth run in the bottom of the fifth inning after a single by Reddick, his second hit of the night. Gattis reached first base on an infield bouncer to Dodgers pitcher Tony Watson, whose wild throw to first allowed Reddick to score.
In their half of the sixth inning, the Dodgers scratched back by scoring two runs. Seager walked, followed by a double by third baseman Justin Turner. Seager scored on right fielder Yasiel Puig’s ground out. Turner scored from third base on Peacock’s wild pitch, making the score 5-3.
The Astros threatened to blow the game wide open in the bottom of the seventh inning. Gurriel lead off with a double to left field. An out later, Gattis was intentionally walked. Houston loaded the bases when McCann hit an infield single. But Dodger reliever Ross Stripling retired center fielder George Springer on a deep drive to center that left Houston fans holding their heads in dismay.
However, by the eighth inning, Peacock looked confident as he retired the last six Dodger batters in a row.
As ESPN’s David Schoenfield reports, when the World Series is tied, the Game 3 winner goes on to win the whole thing 69 percent of the time.
Winner Of High School Golf Tournament Denied Trophy, Because She's A Girl
Emily Nash, shown on Aug. 8 after winning the Massachusetts Golf Association’s WGAM Junior Amateur Championship. This month, in an unrelated high school tournament, Nash was denied a trophy despite her winning score.
Courtesy of the Massachusetts Golf Association
hide caption
toggle caption
Courtesy of the Massachusetts Golf Association
Updated at 4:15 p.m. ET.
Emily Nash was allowed to play. She just wasn’t allowed to win.
Nash, a junior at Lunenburg High School in Lunenburg, Mass., had the lowest score in the Central Mass Division 3 Boys’ Golf Tournament. But the first-place trophy was awarded to a boy who was four strokes behind her, because of the rules of the tournament.
According to the Massachusetts Interscholastic Athletic Association, girls can play in the boys’ golf tournament as part of a team, but they aren’t allowed to be entered as individuals.
That means Nash doesn’t get a trophy, or a spot in the boys state championship.
That was a surprise to her, although her coach was aware of the rule.
“I wasn’t aware that if I won I wouldn’t get the title or the trophy,” she told local TV station WPBF. “I feel like it’s a bit unfair.”
T.J. Auclair, a writer for the PGA, agreed. He called her 3-over-par score “impressive” and wrote that the rule that denied her a trophy is “so bad it makes a shank look good”:
“So, let’s get this straight. Nash’s score which was the best in the field by four strokes, was OK to count toward the team effort, but not OK to count individually?
“And for those wondering, yes, Nash did play from the same tees as the boys, which makes this situation all the more perplexing.
“It’s 2017. This rule sounds like it was created in 1917.”
One volunteer rules official who helped with the tournament told the Worcester Telegram & Gazette the situation is a “real injustice.”
Lunenberg High School doesn’t have a girls’ golf team, WPBF reports. And the boys’ team, despite the boost from Nash’s performance, didn’t qualify for a spot at states.
Nash does qualify to compete in the individual girls’ championship, which will be held in the spring, MIAA says in a statement.
“Female golfers have been welcomed to participate on a boys team in the fall if their school did not sponsor a girls golf team in the spring,” MIAA writes. “It has been clear to participants that female golfers playing in the fall boys team tournament are not participating in an individual capacity. “
“The individual tournament opportunity for female golfers takes place during the spring season,” the group said.
Nash’s father told the TV station, “It is what it is. Those are the rules of golf, and she plays by the rules.”
But pro golfer Brittany Altomare — who is from central Massachusetts, and played in the boys’ state tournament when she was in high school — said the rules should be changed, in this case.
Very disappointing. Gender does not matter she played the same tees a win is a win. She should be allowed to play as an individual in states as I did. https://t.co/jkcicYNC0a
— Brittany Altomare (@Britt_alto12) October 26, 2017
And David S. Cohen, a law professor at Drexel University, says the rule raises Title IX concerns. The law does does allow contact or skill-based sports to be separated by gender, he says — so MIAA could have kept girls out of the boys’ tournament completely.
“But … once they say, ‘We’re going to let girls participate,’ they’re required by Title IX to treat them equally,” he says. “And denying someone the trophy and the championship is far from treating them equally.”
He cited the case of a female Duke student who was allowed to try out for the football team. The courts ruled that once she joined the team, she had to be treated the same as the men.
Meanwhile, the male athlete who was awarded first place offered to give his trophy to Nash, saying she had earned it.
She declined but said she appreciated the gesture.
“He came over and said he didn’t win the tournament, that I did,” she told WPBF. “It was really nice of him and respectful.”

